Using a US Good Faith Estimate as Your Benchmark Against a Quote From Abroad

Why You Need a Domestic Number Before You Compare

Most people who look at surgery in Colombia start with a vague sense that the US price is "a lot." That is not a benchmark. If you want to know whether a quote from a Medellín or Bogotá clinic is a good decision for you, you need an actual US figure for the same operation, from a real facility near you, with the same pieces included.

For self-pay patients in the United States, there is a federal tool built for exactly this: the Good Faith Estimate. It is not perfect, and it does not cover every situation, but it forces US providers to put their expected charges in writing. That makes it the best domestic counterpart to an international quote that most patients can get without paying for a consultation first.

What a Good Faith Estimate Is (and Who Gets One)

The Good Faith Estimate comes from the No Surprises Act. According to a CMS technical-assistance presentation (2022), it applies to people who are uninsured or who choose not to bill their insurance for a particular service. People enrolled in federal programs such as Medicare, Medicaid or TRICARE are not eligible for this particular protection.

The same CMS material lays out the timing rules. If you schedule a service at least three business days ahead, the provider owes you the estimate within one business day. If you schedule ten or more business days out, or you simply ask what something would cost, the provider has up to three business days to send it.

The estimate is supposed to list the items and services the provider expects to deliver, with service and diagnosis codes and the expected charge for each. CMS notes that the requirement was designed to extend to co-providers and co-facilities as well, which matters for surgery, where the surgeon, the anesthesia group and the facility often bill separately.

The dispute safety net

The part most patients never hear about: if your final bill from a single provider or facility comes in at least $400 above that provider's estimate, you can start a patient-provider dispute. CMS says you have 120 calendar days from receiving the initial bill to file. That threshold is assessed separately for each provider, so a surgeon who stayed on budget does not cancel out a facility that went over.

No equivalent mechanism protects you on a bill issued in Colombia. That difference belongs in your comparison, not as a reason to stay home automatically, but as a factor you weigh honestly.

How to Ask for a Good Faith Estimate the Useful Way

A loosely worded request gets a loosely built estimate. If you want something you can actually put next to an international quote, ask with precision.

Name the procedure as the surgeon would. "Laparoscopic cholecystectomy" or "upper blepharoplasty, both eyes" is better than "gallbladder surgery" or "eye lift."
Say clearly that you are self-pay. The rules key off that status. Use the words "uninsured" or "self-pay" in writing.
Ask for every billing party. Request the surgeon, the facility, anesthesia, pathology if tissue is sent to a lab, and any implant or device.
Ask about the setting. A hospital outpatient department and a freestanding ambulatory surgery center can produce very different numbers for the same operation. If both are possible, ask for both.
Ask what is not included. Pre-operative testing, overnight stays and post-operative visits are common gaps.
Keep it in writing. Email or patient-portal messages give you a timestamp and a record.

Some offices will hand you a single bundled cash price instead. That can still be useful, but ask them to confirm in writing which parties the bundle covers, because a bundled price from a surgeon's office sometimes leaves out the anesthesiologist or the hospital entirely.

Lining the Two Documents Up

A Good Faith Estimate and a quote from a Colombian clinic look nothing alike. One is code-heavy and split by provider; the other is often a single package price with a list of inclusions. To compare them, translate both into the same set of rows.

Comparison Row	Where It Shows Up on a US GFE	Where It Shows Up on a Colombia Quote
Surgeon's professional fee	Surgeon's estimate, usually by procedure code	Often inside the package; ask for the split
Facility and operating room	Separate facility estimate, sometimes from a different organization	Usually named as clinic or hospital charges
Anesthesia	Separate anesthesia group, often time-based	Commonly bundled; confirm type of anesthesia
Implant or device	Facility supply line or separate item	Sometimes listed by brand, sometimes just "included"
Overnight stay	Only if expected; observation may be priced differently	Stated in nights, if at all
Pre-op tests	Often excluded or estimated separately	Sometimes required on arrival, at extra cost
Post-op visits	May be within a global surgical period or excluded	Usually a set number of in-person checks
Travel, lodging, recovery time	Usually minimal or none	Not on the quote; you add it yourself

Fill in every cell you can. Where a cell is blank on one side, do not assume it is zero. Write "unknown" and send a follow-up question. The goal is a pair of totals that describe the same surgical event.

A Worked Comparison Without Invented Numbers

Imagine a patient in Ohio planning an elective hernia repair, paying cash. She requests a Good Faith Estimate from a local surgery center and receives three documents: one from the surgeon, one from the center, one from the anesthesia group. The surgeon's estimate includes the operation and the standard post-op period. The center's estimate covers the operating room, recovery room and a mesh supply line. Anesthesia lists an expected time window.

She also has a package quote from a clinic in Colombia. It lists the surgeon, the facility, general anesthesia, mesh and two follow-up visits, all as one figure in US dollars.

Her comparison process:

She adds the three US estimates into a single domestic total.
She asks the Colombian clinic to confirm the mesh type and whether pre-op labs are done locally at extra cost.
She learns the US center's estimate excludes pre-op bloodwork, so she calls her primary care office to price that separately.
She adds flights, about a week of lodging and her own unpaid time off to the Colombia side.
She notes that only the US bill comes with a federal dispute right if it overshoots the estimate.

Only after those steps does she look at which total is lower, and by how much. Sometimes the gap stays wide. Sometimes it narrows enough that the convenience of staying home wins. Either result is a good outcome, because it is an informed one.

Where the Good Faith Estimate Falls Short

Use the estimate as a benchmark, not as gospel.

It reflects a plan, not a guarantee. If your surgeon finds something unexpected during the operation, the scope changes, and so does the bill.
Quality varies by office. Some providers produce clean, itemized estimates. Others send a single line with a code and a number. Push back politely on the thin ones.
It does not include your travel or time costs, even for local surgery. Parking, a caregiver's time off and post-op prescriptions are on you either way.
It cannot tell you about quality. A cheaper US estimate and a cheaper Colombia quote share the same limitation: price says nothing about the surgeon's training or the facility's standards. Confirm credentials separately and talk to a qualified clinician about whether the procedure is right for you.

If You Have Insurance: Check Your Deductible Math Too

Many people who look at surgery abroad are not uninsured. They have a high-deductible plan, or a plan that excludes the procedure, or they have already met part of their out-of-pocket maximum and are unsure whether using insurance at home would be cheaper. For them, a Good Faith Estimate is one benchmark, and their insurer's cost estimate is another.

Before deciding to self-pay, run both numbers:

Insured route: Ask your insurer for an estimate of your share for the procedure at an in-network facility. Many insurers offer cost estimator tools or will provide an estimate by phone. Your share depends on what remains of your deductible, your coinsurance and your out-of-pocket maximum.
Self-pay at home: Ask for the Good Faith Estimate, telling the provider you are choosing not to use insurance.
Self-pay abroad: Use your normalized foreign quote plus travel costs.

Sometimes the insured route is the cheapest of the three, particularly if you are close to your out-of-pocket maximum or the procedure is clearly covered. Sometimes self-pay at home beats both, because some facilities offer meaningful cash discounts. And sometimes the foreign quote still comes out ahead after travel is added. You only know which applies to you if you run all three.

Keep in mind that paying cash for a covered procedure may mean the payment does not count toward your deductible. Ask your insurer how self-pay services are treated before you decide. That detail can matter if you expect other medical costs later in the same plan year.

Write the three totals on one page with their key assumptions. That single page often makes the decision clearer than any amount of browsing price lists.

Turning the Comparison Into a Decision

Once you have two normalized totals, three questions usually settle it:

Is the gap large enough to justify the travel, recovery away from home and the loss of domestic billing protections? Only you can set that line.
Who handles follow-up if something goes wrong after you fly home? If the answer is unclear on the Colombia side, the savings carry more risk.
Are both quotes describing the same operation? A US estimate for a laparoscopic approach and a foreign quote for an open approach are not a fair pairing, even if both say "hernia repair."

If the Colombia option still looks right, use your Good Faith Estimate as leverage for better questions, not haggling. Showing a clinic the US breakdown makes it easier for them to confirm, line by line, what their package actually covers.

Disclaimer: Ranges shown are typical 2026 estimates based on published data and reported patient costs. They are not quotes. Your actual cost depends on surgeon, facility, technique, and clinical factors. Always get a personalized quote before making decisions.

✉

Ready to Turn This Estimate Into a Real Quote?

Submit your details and we walk you through the whole process, start to booked date. See how a request becomes a plan →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get a Good Faith Estimate if I have insurance but plan to pay cash?

The CMS guidance describes self-pay individuals as including people who have coverage but do not intend to bill it for that service. Tell the provider in writing that you are choosing to self-pay so the right process applies.

Does a clinic in Colombia have to give me a Good Faith Estimate?

No. The Good Faith Estimate is a US requirement for US providers. A foreign clinic's written quote is governed by its own terms and local rules, which is why getting inclusions and exclusions in writing matters so much.

What if my US bill ends up higher than the estimate?

Per CMS, if a single provider's bill exceeds that provider's estimate by at least $400, you can start the patient-provider dispute process within 120 calendar days of the initial bill. Keep the estimate and the bill together.

Is a Good Faith Estimate the same as a cash price list?

Not quite. A posted cash price is a general figure. A Good Faith Estimate is meant to reflect the items and services expected for your scheduled care, broken out by provider, which makes it more useful for side-by-side comparison.

Should I tell the Colombian clinic what my US estimate says?

Sharing the structure of the US estimate can help a clinic confirm which items their package includes. Focus the conversation on scope and inclusions rather than trying to negotiate a lower number.